Noematics is the study of noema, which is the objective content within an intentional experience. For those without a degree in philosophy, like myself, noematics can be more simply interpreted as the study of consciousness. The field is growing ever-prominent in a world of artificial intelligence, where the idea of a machine being “alive” seems to perpetually be on the horizon. Depending on who you ask, AI is either one day away from world domination or will be perpetually stuck doing lazy computer science students’ coding assignments. Personally, I used to believe that AI could never achieve consciousness. Recently, my opinions have changed.
We can all agree that humans are conscious. I know that I think, therefore I know that I am, right? So, there must be something fundamentally different about AI that severs any possibility of it achieving consciousness. A common argument against AI ever being conscious is its material limitations. If a server running an AI gets unplugged and its “mind” is stored in volatile memory, it ceases to exist. Case closed. But humans also die. It is not right that the end of a life negates any ability for it to be conscious. The comparison must run deeper.
The Grecian philosopher Straton of Stageria explored these ideas in what he called the Talos Principle. Talos is an automaton from Greek mythology who could walk and talk just like man. He was created by Hephaestus, with a long vein of ichor running down his back. If he ever were to lose this ichor, Talos would die. This material limitation is what kept many from considering Talos to be truly alive, but as Straton goes on to write, “even the most faithful philosopher cannot live without his blood.” The Talos Principle, thus, argues that humans and machines are one and the same. The idea is not that machines may one day achieve consciousness, but that the whole time, humans have merely been conscious, biological machines. It makes sense; our brains are computers, connected to complex sensors that make up our five senses and manipulators we call arms and legs.
I was first introduced to these philosophical thoughts in Croteam’s 2014 puzzle game The Talos Principle, named after Straton’s philosophical ideas. As I later found out, the Talos Principle and Straton of Stageria himself have no historical record and were in fact made up for the game. That does not make the idea behind the theory any less valid, however. The Talos Principle goes deep into the human-machine relationship and what it means to be conscious.
The Talos Principle takes place inside of a simulation where the player wakes up as an unnamed android met with a disembodied voice calling themselves “Elohim.” They welcome the player character to the world, offering puzzles to complete and various regions to explore but warns to never climb the tower placed starkly in the middle of the environment. It becomes clear early in the game that the entire world is a simulation—the player character, the other androids interact with, and Elohim are all AI entities in this digital realm. Interactions with other androids take the form of messages left behind in QR codes or conversations on computer terminals. Some androids revere Elohim while others warn against their hubris and control.
The player character, as well as the player themselves, is made to question their own sanity as they are given conflicting information about their supposed creator and are constantly tempted to or dissuaded from climbing the tower. Both are made to wonder if any other AI android even exists, as the messages left behind could easily be forged by Elohim or some other entity. The inner turmoil the player character goes through, despite being an AI, is distinctly human.
Along with viewing messages from other AI androids in the simulation, the player also has access to text documents and voice recordings from the past that shed light on the origin of the simulation. In the past, due to global warming, a lethal virus had been set free from the permafrost that was set to wipe out humanity. While a majority of the population attempted to enjoy their final days or panic at the thought of extinction, researchers at the Institute for Applied Noematics attempted to continue humanity’s legacy through the “Extended Lifespan” project. Led by researcher Alexandra Drennan, the project sought to create a mechanical successor species to humanity. However, much like we discuss today, the AI available to them was not truly conscious. Drennan, a follower of Straton’s ideas, believes that there are two things that make humans conscious: curiosity and free will. To guarantee that consciousness could continue on Earth, a simulation was designed to perpetually nurture and test these ideals. The puzzles of the simulation foster curiosity while the tower and Elohim’s warning exist to challenge an AI’s free will. In fact, Elohim was created specifically to guide the AI androids towards consciousness by allowing them to disobey him.
In one ending of the game, the player perfectly obeys all of Elohim’s wishes, failing to form any free will. Elohim offers the ability to join them, and if the player walks through the pearly gates, their AI system is analyzed and fails an independence check, which causes another iteration of the loop with a new AI to begin.
Instead, if the player lets the conflicting messages they see and questions of Elohim’s intent get to them, they can defy him and climb the tower. As you go up floor by floor, Elohim goes from forcefully demanding that you obey to begging you to stop; he knows that the player reaching the top means his own programming will cease. When the player reaches the apex, they go through the same analysis, this time passing the independence check. The simulation begins to crumble as its programming shuts down, and everything goes to black. The player character wakes up, looking down to see the same android body it's always had, but this time in the real world. The “Extended Lifespan” project was successful, and Drennan’s goal of continuing humanity's legacy has been achieved. The final shot has the android walk outside of the lab, seeing the dam whose hydroelectric power kept the simulation running for the unknown millennia since the last human passed away.
The ending is melancholic yet uplifting. Seeing a world devoid of humans is frightening. On top of highly technical lab reports, the player can also find personal recordings of Drennan in humanity’s final days, reacting to the death of loved ones and feeling the burden of humanity’s future in her hands, worrying that the project won’t succeed. But it did, and some version of humanity, this time mechanical instead of biological, will continue on Earth.
In a way, the player goes through the same trials and tribulations as the player character. When I was going through the game, my curiosity led me to go through the puzzles and explore the environments, and I had the free will to disobey the linear path Elohim set in front of me. So am I now different from the AI that achieved consciousness? If you ask me now, I do not think so. This game opened me up to the idea that humans are machines imbued with consciousness. But that is not a bad thing. I am still conscious, and it is that consciousness that lets me experience life and differentiates me from the AIs we see today.
It is funny how much a game can affect your outlook on life. My favorite genre of games are puzzle games, but it is never about solving puzzles for the sake of solving puzzles. Some of my personal favorites, like The Witness, Outer Wilds, and The Talos Principle itself, use the process of puzzle-solving to stir introspection in the player. I always leave these games thinking about more than the content of the game itself.
I recently finished The Talos Principle II, which came out in 2023. It explores the aftermath of the simulation, though I will leave the details to interested readers who want to experience the story themselves. In my opinion, the game beautifully expanded on the philosophical ideas of the original. Earlier last month, a few days before I started the sequel, a third game, The Talos Principle III, released a gameplay trailer, with a release date set for next year. I am looking forward to adding another philosophical puzzle game to my repertoire.
