Did you vote?

If the answer is no, there are plenty of possible reasons. Maybe you missed the registration deadline, or your ballot never made it to the top of a long to-do list. Maybe you looked at the options and decided that nobody in power was listening to you. Those are very different reasons, but from the outside they look exactly the same: one fewer vote.

The second reason is one I understand best, and honestly, it is fair. In the Harvard Youth Poll this spring, only 15 percent of young Americans said they trust the federal  government, the lowest in more than 26 years of the poll. Half agreed that people like them have no say in what the government does. If you believe nobody is listening, voting can start to feel like a lot of effort for very little.

However, I keep coming back to what we do with that feeling. CIRCLE at Tufts estimates that about 27 percent of young people voted in this month’s midterm elections. That is the second-highest youth turnout for a midterm in 30 years, behind only 2018. It is also still a minority: nearly three out of every four young people did not vote. Staying home can feel like a way of sending a message, but a skipped ballot cannot say why it was skipped. Whether you were frustrated or just busy, the count looks exactly the same.

So who is responsible when people feel unheard? Two philosophers, writing about two thousand years apart, give different answers, and I think each one is half right.

Mencius lived in the fourth century BC, when China was divided into warring states with their own rulers, who were often at war. He traveled to different states trying to persuade their rulers to govern according to Confucian ideals. His central political idea was that a king keeps the mandate to rule only if he cares for the people and properly fulfills his responsibilities. That makes trust something a government has to earn, not something it is owed. In other words, the people in power bear the burden of proof. So when only 15 percent of young Americans say they trust the federal government, Mencius would not call that apathy, but rather a warning sign about the people in power.

But Mencius had little patience for stepping away. He criticized the Yangists, who advocated for avoiding political participation at a time when it often posed danger, and he read that as selfishness. Scholars think the Yangists were probably not indifferent to others or to politics at all. I think the same is true of many people who skip elections today. They care, but stepping back does not hold anyone accountable. Mencius leaves it there, with a government that has to earn trust and citizens who should not walk away.

Jean-Jacques Rousseau, writing in the 18th century, builds his whole argument on the half Mencius only hints at, which is what citizens owe. He believed power belongs to the people, so they should take part in public life themselves instead of leaving it to others. In The Social Contract, he wrote that once citizens would rather serve with their money than with their own persons, the state is not far from its fall. His examples were paying troops to fight and naming deputies to attend meetings so that everyone else could stay home. He even went after the idea of representative government itself. He said the English believed themselves free, but were free only while electing members of parliament, and that slavery overtook them as soon as the election was over.

Rousseau meant that as a criticism of voting, and I would not go that far. But his warning still fits. If election day is the one moment your say is counted, staying home hands that moment to someone else. The decision still gets made by the people who showed up, and their priorities may not match yours.

I think both of them are right. Mencius is right that the government has to earn our trust, and Rousseau is right that we cannot wait for it to do that from the sidelines.

All of this raises the question: does voting actually get us heard? Not always. A study published in Political Behavior analyzed more than 270,000 survey respondents in 40 countries from 1996 to 2016, and found that voters are at most only slightly better represented than nonvoters. It also found that people active in several kinds of non-electoral politics, such as demonstrating, were better represented than people who were inactive.

Research from Britain points in the other direction, with a warning attached. In a 2014 analysis for Democratic Audit UK, researchers compared how the government’s 2010 spending cuts affected people who voted in that year’s election with those who did not. Nonvoters got a raw deal from the cuts, but the authors admit this tells us nothing about causality, because they cannot know whether it happened because those people were nonvoters. They also found that by 2010, the turnout rate of a typical 70-year-old was 36 percentage points higher than that of a typical 20-year-old. Their argument is that unequal turnout tilts politics toward the groups that vote, which unleashes a vicious cycle of disaffection and under-representation for the groups whose participation is falling. 

I cannot tell you that a vote guarantees anyone will listen. Still, I think voting is the most basic way to have a voice. It is not the only way, and the 40-country study suggests it is not always the most effective. But it is the one that asks the least: no connections, no money, and only a little of your time. If you skip it, you are effectively silencing yourself in the one place where everyone is, at least on paper, counted the same.

I still think distrust is a good reason to demand more from the people in charge. It is just not a good reason to disappear. A skipped ballot cannot explain itself, but a cast one at least shows that we were there.