Introduction
While the 2005 NFL Draft didn’t have as many interesting plot twists as last year’s draft (i.e. Eli Manning-Phillip Rivers trade), it was just as exciting. After months of speculation, quarterback Alex Smith of Utah was taken number one by the San Francisco 49ers. Running back Ronnie Brown went to Miami Dolphins at number two, wide receiver Braylon Edwards went number three to the Cleveland Browns, and surprisingly, Maurice Clarett went to Denver in the last pick of the third round. The 2005 draft class might not have had as many blue-chip prospects as previous classes, but we will have to wait until a few years down the road before we can really judge this class. With that being said, let’s look at the teams who may have helped or hurt themselves the most on paper.
Winners
Arizona Cardinals—The awful Cardinals finally have something to be proud about. Antrel Rolle is a good physical corner, and running back J.J. Arrington would’ve been a first round pick if he were few inches taller. Linebacker Daryl Blackstock and guard Elton Brown were steals in the third and fourth round.
San Diego Chargers—Rush linebacker Shawne Merriman and Luis Castillo fit perfectly in their 3-4 defense. Diminutive running back Darren Sproles will be a great change-of-pace back and special teamer.
Losers
Green Bay Packers—Picking up Aaron Rodgers gives them their successor for Brett Favre, but the Packers need defensive help. They used two picks on wide receiver instead, and the defensive players they did draft are all projects.
Washington Redskins—In what has to be one of the most puzzling moves of the draft, the Redskins gave up a first and fourth round pick in 2006, and their third round 2005 pick, for quarterback Jason Campbell. The Redskins had already invested a first round pick in Patrick Ramsey and signed Mark Brunell to $43 million contract. They should’ve drafted a wide receiver to replace unhappy Rod Gardner.
